The Legal Significance and Practical Implications of the Finch Decision of the UK Supreme Court – A New Hope for Climate or Business as Usual? – Journal of Environmental Law
The assessment of Scope 3 downstream emissions from oil and gas production has been the subject of litigation in the United Kingdom for many years with environmental campaigners calling for its inclusion into the environmental impact assessment, and the authorities and the industry maintaining that these emissions are outside the scope of the assessment. The dispute appears to have been resolved by the UK Supreme Court decision in Finch v Surrey County Council [2024] UKSC 20, which established that emissions resulting from burning the produced oil and gas – wherever that takes place – must be considered in the environmental impact assessment. Together with the Labour Government’s platform of no new oil and gas exploration, the decision delivered hope to climate campaigners and despair to the oil and gas industry. This analysis reviews the Finch decision with a focus on its legal significance and practical implications for the UK energy sector and beyond.
Journal of Environmental Law, 17th June 2025
Source: academic.oup.com